| A |
Cap Anson, Al Atkinson, Bob Gilman Allen, Doug Allison, Harry Arundel |
B |
Bob Black, Ross Barnes, Oyster Burns, Pete Browning, Dick Burns |
| C |
Dan Collins, Bob Caruthers, John Clapp, John Cassidy, Larry Corcoran |
D |
Daisy Davis, Bert Dorr, Fred Dunlap, Jacob Doyle, Ed Delahanty |
| E |
Dave Eggler, Billy Earle, Buck Ewing, Henry Easterday, Jake Evans |
F |
Charlie Ferguson, John Fisher, Jocko Flynn, Jim Fogarty, Dickie Flowers |
| G |
Charlie Geggus, George Gore, Emil Gross, Joe Gerhardt, Mike Griffin |
H |
Guy Hecker, Hardie Henderson, Dick Higham, Paul Hines, Billy Hamilton |
| I |
Charlie Irwin, Arthur Irwin, Bert Inks, Charlie Ingraham |
J |
Dick Johnston, Hughie Jennings, Jack Jones, Mike Jones, Fielder Jones |
| K |
Matt Kilroy, Lon Knight, Jim Keenan, King Kelly, Tim Keefe |
L |
Herman Long, Arlie Latham, Bill Lange, Milo Lockwood, Fred Lewis |
| M |
Ed Morris, Bobby Mitchell, Bobby Mathews, Jack Manning, Dick McBride |
N |
Billy Nash, Tricky Nichols, The Only Nolan, Candy Nelson, Jack Neagle |
| O |
Jack O'Brien, Jim O'Rourke, Darby O'Brien, Dave Orr, Frank Olin |
P |
Abner Powell, Al Pratt, Lip Pike, Frank Pearce, Chris Paff |
| Q |
Paddy Quinn, Joe Quest, Joe Quinn, U Quinlan |
R |
Toad Ramsey, John Richmond, John Reccius, John Reilly, Danny Richardson |
| S |
Al Spalding, Scott Stratton, Bill Stearns, Ed Seward, Ed Stratton |
T |
Sam Thompson, Adonis Terry, Mike Tiernan, Cannonball Titcomb, Harry Taylor |
| U |
|
V |
Peek-A-Boo Veach, George Van Haltren, Jake Virtue, Alex Voss, Bill Vinton |
| W |
Monte Ward, Jim Whitney, Rynie Wolters, Ned Williamson, Chicken Wolf |
X |
|
| Y |
Tom York, Cy Young, Mike Young, Bill Yeatman |
Z |
George Zettlein, Charles Zimmer, Fred Zahner, George Ziegler |
|
