 |
|
| Name | Pos | Team | Age | DOB | POB | Nationality | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Salary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Palmer, Billy | RP | Free Agent | 25 | 05/05/1863 | St. Louis | USA | Right | Right | 178 cm | 80 kg | - |
| Pappas, Nick | RP | Kansas City Cowboys | 29 | 03/12/1859 | Palestine | USA | Left | Left | 175 cm | 79 kg | P408 |
| Parsons, Charlie | CL | Philadelphia Athletics | 25 | 07/18/1863 | Unknown | USA | Left | Left | 178 cm | 74 kg | P416 |
| Pechiney, George | RP | Cincinnati Red Stockings | 26 | 09/20/1861 | Cincinnati | USA | Right | Right | 175 cm | 85 kg | P250 |
| Peltz, John | LF | Cleveland Blues | 27 | 04/23/1861 | New Orleans | USA | Right | Right | 173 cm | 78 kg | P240 |
| Penny, Zion | LF | Louisville Colonels | 24 | 05/12/1864 | Gilmore | USA | Right | Right | 177 cm | 87 kg | P372 |
| Peoples, Jimmy | SS | Louisville Colonels | 24 | 10/08/1863 | Big Beaver | USA | Right | Right | 173 cm | 92 kg | P305 |
| Pettit, Bob | RF | Chicago White Stockings | 27 | 07/19/1861 | Williamstown | USA | Left | Right | 175 cm | 72 kg | - |
| Pfeffer, Fred | SS | Philadelphia Quakers | 28 | 03/17/1860 | Louisville | USA | Right | Right | 178 cm | 86 kg | P462 |
| Phillips, Marr | SS | Kansas City Cowboys | 31 | 06/16/1857 | Pittsburgh | USA | Right | Right | 168 cm | 76 kg | P260 |
| Pierce, Gracie | CF | Free Agent | 28 | 05/05/1860 | New York | USA | Left | Right | 180 cm | 83 kg | - |
| Pinkney, George | 1B | Cleveland Blues | 29 | 01/11/1859 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 170 cm | 76 kg | P260 |
| Polhemus, Mark | RF | Kansas City Cowboys | 27 | 10/04/1860 | Brooklyn | USA | Right | Right | 168 cm | 84 kg | - |
| Poorman, Tom | RF | Brooklyn Bridegrooms | 31 | 10/14/1856 | Lock Haven | USA | Left | Right | 170 cm | 63 kg | P260 |
| Porter, Henry | SP | Indianapolis Hoosiers | 30 | 06/05/1858 | Vergennes | USA | Right | Right | 178 cm | 64 kg | P280 |
| Powell, Jim | 1B | Baltimore Orioles | 28 | 08/30/1859 | Richmond | USA | Right | Right | 178 cm | 78 kg | P260 |
| Powell, Martin | 1B | Free Agent | 33 | 03/25/1855 | Fitchburg | USA | Left | Left | 183 cm | 81 kg | - |
| Prince, Walter | RF | Cleveland Blues | 27 | 05/09/1861 | Amherst | USA | Left | Right | 175 cm | 71 kg | P424 |
| Purcell, Blondie | LF | Kansas City Cowboys | 35 | 03/16/1853 | Paterson | USA | Right | Right | 175 cm | 71 kg | P260 |
| Pyle, Shadow | RP | Cleveland Blues | 26 | 11/29/1861 | Reading | USA | Right | Left | 173 cm | 63 kg | P374 |
